CEC Movie Club: Rob Kooyman – Gondwana, Northern NSW

Rob Kooyman, forest ecologist of note, traces the history of the ancient forests of Gondwana, until now, bringing the focus to the forests here, the forests of Northern NSW.

The new 29 min film by Frontier Films (David Bradbury).

Proudly presented here in association with the The Caldera Environment Centre.

About Rob Kooyman … protected area and conservation management … large-scale rainforest restoration … the evolutionary ecology, botany, and paleo-botany of the Gondwanan, Australian, and Southeast Asian rainforests … the rate and direction of recovery from disturbance of rainforest types around the world … collaborative global studies of rainforest species distributions, and forest dynamics and ecology … Research Fellow with Macquarie University, and an Honorary Research Associate with the Royal Botanic Gardens Sydney. read more

Share

UN Secretary General: “Humanity is waging war on nature. This is suicidal.”

“Biodiversity is collapsing. Ecosystems are disappearing before our eyes. Human activities are at the root of our descent toward chaos.”

The UN Secretary General listed the human-inflicted wounds on the natural world: the spread of deserts; wetlands lost; forests cut down; oceans overfished and choked with plastic; dying coral reefs; air pollution, …

“Next year gives us a wealth of opportunities to stop the plunder and start the healing.” Said UN Secretary General Antonio Guterres.

The UN Secretary General was speaking at an address on the release of the ‘UN State of the Global Climate 2020 – Provisional Report’, published by the UN World Meteorological Office. read more

Share

The NSW Govt. Inquiry Report: ‘Koala Populations and Habitat in New South Wales’

The need to stop logging in public native forests did not receive majority support from committee members and is therefore not a recommendation in the report.

The government is required to respond to the recommendations of the report within six months.

A highlighted copy of the report is attached below, and is available also on the inquiry website, along with submissions, transcripts of evidence and other inquiry documents.

PC7-Koala-populations-and-habitatDownload
Share

CEC Movie Club: Forest Defenders – The Fight to Protect Tasmania’s Native Forests

Forest Defenders: The Fight to Protect Tasmania’s Native Forests, takes you straight to where ordinary people are stepping up to protect some of the most incredible forests in the world from the archaic practice of native forest logging.

Made entirely by those involved in the fight, this film has a simple aim: To inspire you to join them and take Action for Earth. 

“…, captures the passion, bravery and humanity of the activists fighting to save Tasmania’s ancient forests from the chainsaws, bulldozers and firebombs.”

Watch the movie here

Pledge here to hear about more opportunities to get involved with their actions: https://www.bobbrown.org.au/t_pledge_…

Made by the Bob Brown Foundation in collaboration with The Alleged Arts Collective, Ramji Creations & Manic Seeds Media. read more

Share

North-East NSW Native Forests will fuel the Redbank Ex-Coal-Fired Power Station, making it one of world’s ten biggest biomass power plants.

From NEFA [North East Forest Alliance]:

Hunter Energy is currently seeking expressions of interest for timber from across north-east NSW to fuel their ex-coal Redbank Power Station, with plans to restart the facility in mid 2021 fed by native forests to make it one of world’s ten biggest biomass power plants.

Estimates are that just this power station will require one million tonnes of biomass to be taken from north-east NSW’s forests and plantations each year, with 60% of this to come from private forests.

“This is sheer madness as burning this volume will release some 1.8 million tonnes of CO2 into the atmosphere each year to fuel climate heating, increased droughts, heatwaves and more intense bushfires, while increasing forest degradation and hastening species extinctions. read more

Share

NEFA Weekly Forest News: Forest Media 6

From NEFA [North East Forest Alliance]:

We did well with our Kill the Bill demonstrations, with good stories on Prime and NBN, though the National Party’s standard response is that we are ignorant and misguided. Bangalow Koalas also organised a successful event with 50 kids from the Byron Community Primary School. The hypocrisy of Gladys granting 0.06 ha to the Port Macquarie Koala Hospital at the same time the Feds backed up her Government’s decision to clear 50ha for a quarry at Port Stephens was noticed. Finding a collective noun for Koalas may not be an issue soon, when a zoo will do. Paddy Manning gives a detailed summary of forest issues in southern Australia, highlighting its economic absurdity. Millers want a domestic reservation policy for plantation timber, so they should be happy with China’s ban.

The Bushfire Royal Commission’s finding that climate heating exists, and is getting worse, caused a flurry of inaction. Our bushfires injected a smoke cloud 35km into the stratosphere that travelled 66,000 km over 3 months – at least it cooled the earth. You may hope that Deloite Access Economics’ assessment that continued inaction on climate change will cost us more than $3 trillion over the next 50 years would be listened too.

Meanwhile record fires, droughts and introduced pests continue to devastate forests around the world. Despite reafforestation commitments we continue to clear them and reduce logging rules to obtain dwindling timber. True to form the Morrison Government has asked for 5 Australian Biosphere Reserves to be delisted. The benefits of forest bathing are being increasingly recognised in the unfolding apocalypse.

The likely defeat of the meglomaniacal Trump (assuming his coup fails) ) heralds a far better future for action on climate chaos and environmental care, leaving Morrison increasingly isolated.

Dailan

NEFA weren’t the only ones trying to kill the bill today:

https://www.winghamchronicle.com.au/story/6998929/environment-groups-join-to-protest-koala-legislation-in-taree/

Local environment groups are joining forces to hold a protest in Taree on Friday, November 6.

Midcoast Knitting Nannas, Extinction Rebellion Midcoast, North East Forest Alliance and Save Bulga Forest say the theme of the protest is ‘Koala protection is going backwards’ and they are protesting the weakening of bushland and koala protections legislation.

https://www.echo.net.au/2020/11/kids-for-koalas-in-byron/

This morning saw around 50 kids from the Byron Community Primary School up to the age of nine out in Byron making their voices heard in support of koalas.

‘We should look after koala habitat because they need a home just like us,’ said Mimi, aged 7. This was supported by Tommy, aged 8, who said ‘koalas need trees to live and the trees also clean the air for us!’

‘I think it’s important that we do not cut down eucalyptus trees because that’s the only habitat they can live in.’ Willow 7

‘We should stop destroying koala land because it’s alive like us.’ Bodhi 7

‘We urge people to email members of the Legislative Council in the Upper House and voice your concern now.’

https://www.goulburnpost.com.au/story/7002125/politicians-hypocrisy-is-a-bigger-issue-than-koalas/

In the face of widespread criticism, the NSW Premier Gladys Berejiklian, who had overseen these failed polices and increased land clearing and development where koalas live, announced that she wanted to be “known as the Premier who saved the koala”.

Well it WAS pretty simple after all. Basically you identify areas where koalas are known to live and breed, and protect the trees they use. A new koala State Environment Planning policy was put in place.

While publicly acting as though she had stood up to the National Party leader, it wasn’t long before the Premier agreed on a compromise. It’s the Local Land Services Amendment (Miscellaneous) Bill 2020. It contradicts all previous public statements by the Premier, and will reduce current protections for koalas, and see MORE of their homes cleared in NSW.

The same old routine of say one thing publicly, then do another. Introduce one policy to media applause, then undermine with country polices and exemptions.

Repercussions of Koala killing spree spread:

https://www.newcastleherald.com.au/story/6992497/why-a-good-outcome-for-koalas-is-no-ley-down-misere/

Hanson, the quarry operator, has now satisfied all the regulatory licenses to go ahead and clear critical koala habitat. But do they have the social license to operate? A social license for Brandy Hill can only be achieved once the project has the ongoing approval and broad acceptance of the local, national and international community.

Minister Ley’s decision to approve the project could signify to the international community that the Australian federal government does not really value koalas. This comes at a time when our most respected naturalist, Sir David Attenborough has said: “We should be in no doubt. Biodiversity loss, the destruction of nature, is as grave an issue as climate change. They both work together to destabilise the world we rely upon”.

Many people say this project does not pass the pub test, and for me personally, I drink at this pub. If you had seen what I have in my research, you’d know we don’t have that many koalas left. If you had walked through Port Stephens listening for the call of a male koala as I have, you would understand why this decision was gut-wrenching. If you ask Save Port Stephens Koalas, or other conservation scientists, clearing koala habitat will always fail the pub test

https://www.newsofthearea.com.au/quarry-wins-federal-ministers-decision-at-brandy-hill-while-community-vows-to-fight-on-60859

The public outcry to the quarry expansion decision has inspired local action groups to continue campaigning and are currently working on strategies to stop the loss of this koala habitat.

Chantal Paslow, a key local spokesperson for the Save Port Stephens Koalas campaign, told News Of The Area, “The Minister has chosen rocks over koalas.

“This fight isn’t over yet, we have commenced a petition on change.org.

https://www.portstephensexaminer.com.au/story/6990042/brandy-hill-koala-campaigners-vow-to-fight-on/

https://www.marieclaire.com.au/koala-habitat-destroyed-port-stephens

“The minister’s statement says this area didn’t burn—that’s the whole point. This is koala habitat,” Parslow Redman said. “This just shows that nothing will stop this government from destroying koala habitat.

“It’s a heartbreaking decision,” she added.

https://www.newcastleherald.com.au/story/6991908/without-a-breeding-program-koala-extinction-will-be-sooner-rather-than-later-port-stephens-koalas/

https://independentaustralia.net/politics/politics-display/sussan-leys-approval-of-quarry-development-set-to-destroy-koala-habitat,14483

IN WHAT MUST SURELY be the most egregious act of hypocrisy, NSW Premier Gladys Berejiklian gifted Port Macquarie Koala Hospital with 6,000 square metres of land to help the hospital expand.

The same day, as a result of her government fast-tracking approval of the Brandy Hill Quarry Expansion Project in Port Stephens, Federal Environment Minister Sussan Ley approved the development.

The reality of koala survival in NSW is becoming grimmer every day. Every square foot of koala habitat needs to be protected if koalas are to survive in the state.

Koalas are going extinct now. The species is dying by inches as one inappropriate development after another is given the go-ahead by state and federal governments.

Meantime, back in Berejiklian’s corner, Deputy Premier John Barilaro has described koalas as “tree rats” according to an article in the Sydney Morning Herald. As Minister for the Department of Resources, logging of koala habitat continues in spite of massive public protest.

https://www.portnews.com.au/story/6995634/protesting-the-states-koala-kill-bill/

So, Gladys comes to town to gift the Koala Hospital the land it currently occupies.

While she is being photographed, State Forest continue to decimate habitat that survived bushfires, quarry expansions into koala habitat proceed and her team rush the Koala Kill Bill through Parliament, for a vote in the Upper House next week.

So, one day, a multi-million dollar Koala Hospital might be the only place to see a koala.

https://www.portnews.com.au/story/6995641/koala-extinction-now-more-likely/

Changes made to the Koala Habitat Protection State Environmental Plan (SEPP) and a local Land Services Amendment (Miscellaneous) Bill were passed in the NSW Legislative Assembly, (the Lower house) this week and will be put before the Upper House in November. These changes were demanded by the State National Party and overturn laws and regulations designed to increase protections for declining Koala populations here on the Mid North Coast.

The laws and policies needed tightening not relaxing. The government is taking us backwards many decades, to extremely weak and ineffective regulation, well short of providing the protections needed for koalas.

https://www.echo.net.au/2020/11/land-clearing-rule-threatens-koala-habitat/

According to analysis undertaken by WWF and the office of Independent NSW MLC Justin Field, a mapping analysis of the NSW Government’s plan to allow rural landholders to clear 25 metre fire breaks around properties, threatens tens of thousands of hectares of bushland on the NSW North Coast, including significant areas of koala habitat.

Mr Field said the analysis, conducted in four local Government areas across the state including the Clarence, Port Stephens, Shoalhaven and Wollondilly, showed more than 44,000 hectares were at risk, including almost 12,000 hectares of known koala habitat. ‘This analysis implies that hundreds of thousands of hectares of bushland will be at risk across the state as a result of this policy.

‘The Government has indicated it will bring legislation to Parliament in November to implement the changes.

‘It looks to me that this is just the latest in an anti-science ideological response from some in the Government who are taking advantage of the bushfire crisis to push their agenda to clear more land.

What to call a horde of Koalas?:

https://www.smh.com.au/culture/books/a-koallective-noun-for-koalas-a-torpor-a-caramelli-a-barilaro-20201026-p568le.html

Koalas, on the other hand, well … that’s it. There is no word. Kangaroos have mobs, foxes have skulks, but koalas: the cupboard is bare.

Robina Dwyer highlighted this vacuum, writing to say, “There are collective nouns for almost all animals and I see no reason for koalas to miss out. With this in mind, may I suggest a cuddle would be appropriate.”

Yet early colonial journals spent more time quibbling over how to spell the Dharug word, the Anglo-manglings ranging from koolah to cullawine, just as the animal itself was dubbed a native bear, an Australian monkey (or sloth) and Billy Bluegum.

… Doze, for one, was another hit, honouring the leaf-muncher’s lethargy, in league with torpor, inertia, repose, session (‘’because they’re stoned during waking hours’’), kip and coma.

Koma too was tendered, the improvised K popular among responses, appearing in kollection, kuddle, koalaboration and koalition. …

Barilaro was another eponym, a wink at NSW’s National Party leader, John Barilaro, who’d lobbied in September for more logging inroads, despite several areas being valued as prime koala habitat.

Paddy Manning gives a detailed summary of forest issues in southern Australia:

https://www.themonthly.com.au/issue/2020/november/1604149200/paddy-manning/coupe-de-gr-ce

The Imlay Road twists inland from the southern coast of New South Wales, between Eden and the Victorian border, through a string of state forests: Timbillica, Yambulla, Nungatta. As on many stretches of highway in 2020, the landscape is thoroughly depressing. For more than 50 kilometres, panic growth blurs blackened trunks and limbs as far as the eye can see – a reminder of the flame heights that terrified residents and firefighters through Australia’s horrific Black Summer bushfires. To the casual observer, the epicormic shoots are a sign the trees are alive. To the trained eye, the shoots show what stress the trees are under – a silent green shriek. Recovery will be slow, and is far from assured.

According to federal government figures, NSW lost 880,000 hectares, or 47 per cent of the native forest managed by the state’s Forestry Corporation, along with a quarter of its plantation estate. In the worst-hit area, the South Coast, more than 80 per cent of state forest marked for timber production was fire-affected, much of it heavily. … In the state’s native forests nowadays, says Australian National University forest ecologist, professor David Lindenmayer, “the worst-kept secret in the industry is that there’s no timber left”.

The forestry agencies in both states appear to have badly misjudged the public mood, encountering staunch resistance from activists and residents determined to protect what was left – burnt and unburnt alike. In Victoria, protesters shut down logging across seven state forestry coupes, from Mount Cole in the west to Lakes Entrance in the east. “In a climate emergency, we feel it’s time to transition [into plantation logging] and protect what native forests we have left,” said local spokesperson Nic Fox.

In NSW, the state’s Environment Protection Authority (EPA) imposed strict new requirements for post-fire logging, stipulating all giant or hollow-bearing trees must be protected, but reports of breaches quickly emerged. At the Mogo and South Brooman state forests, near Batemans Bay on the South Coast, local citizen scientists recorded well over 100 breaches of the new code of practice, taking legally admissible geotagged photos.

[Eden woodchip mill owner] As he surveyed the fire damage in January, McComb told The Australian there would be a short-term glut of burnt wood, and the longer-term future of forestry in the region required a rethink. “This is a watershed event in terms of forest management in Australia,” he said. “It looks like the entire resource has been wiped out.”

Five months later, McComb hosted Prime Minister Scott Morrison at the Eden mill, where Morrison announced some $50 million in funding for the timber industry, including infrastructure grants of up to $5 million. October’s federal budget lifted post-bushfire forestry industry assistance to $65 million.

To get its message out, Pentarch has set up a charitable organisation, Forest and Wood Communities Australia (FWCA), ostensibly to represent timber workers. FWCA is active on Facebook sharing pro-forestry, pro-gun and pro-Trump memes, but with just over 500 followers, the group looks like an astroturf-marketing operation. McComb is a director but will not speak on its behalf.

Forestry has taken a hit from COVID and bushfire, but the industry was already staring at decline. According to a September report by business consultancy IBISWorld, revenue and profits from forestry and logging have fallen by 1 per cent and 7 per cent per annum respectively over the past five years. The sector has a $4.7 billion turnover and employs some 10,100 people directly, but has shed 4000 jobs over the past decade, and the number of enterprises has more than halved. Corporatised state government forestry agencies are the dominant players, alongside a few big private plantation managers, such as Boston-based Hancock. There has been a long-run shift to plantations: native-forest logging now accounts for roughly 15 per cent of industry revenue.

A subsequent state parliamentary inquiry warned this year that koalas were on track to become extinct in NSW by 2050, but a planning policy designed to stop habitat clearing nearly blew up the state Coalition government in September. A compromise was reached, which did away with contentious maps of koala habitat and allowed private land clearing. Animals for Australia is now building a case, although NSW’s Forestry Corporation can’t be sued by third parties as VicForests was.

Field says the native forestry industry was barely making money before the fires, is facing a wood-supply crisis and is almost certainly unprofitable, despite ongoing public subsidies. “It’s a loss-making business,” he says. “It’s costing us, and there’s not that many jobs in it either. If we re-imagine the future of these forests, as ecological reserves, as recreational reserves, even some commercial development to take the pressure off commercial development in national parks, that’s many more jobs, particularly for regional communities”. Field points out that low-cost carbon abatement could be achieved by allowing our state forests to mature. “If you want to hit net zero emissions by 2050 in NSW, and take the pressure off other industry sectors, stopping native-forest logging is one of the best ways to do it.”

From the environment movement has come a new determination to end native-forest logging altogether. But the forestry industry has bipartisan support, and the Greens were on their own in August when they introduced a Senate motion calling on the federal government to immediately protect all high-conservation value forests in the wake of the VicForests case.

The federal assistant minister for forestry is Jonathon Duniam, an ex-staffer of arch conservative Tasmanian senator Eric Abetz. Duniam recently claimed in the Senate that the environmental movement would not stop “until the last chainsaw falls silent”. Today it was native-forest harvesting, he warned, but tomorrow it would be plantations. Not one Greens politician or conservationist I have spoken with has called for an end to plantation forestry.

In some forest types it can take 60 to 100 years before a tree gets to sawlog age. With bushfire risk increasing, there is now an 80 per cent chance that trees will be burned before they reach maturity, says David Lindenmayer. He compares native forest logging with overfishing, as an industry spiralling down the value chain – in forestry’s case, from taking high-value species to ever-lower-grade timber suitable only for use as woodchip or (the worst fear of conservationists) burning as biomass. There could be far more jobs in saving forests – letting them mature and managing them to reduce fire risk, produce clean air and water, store carbon, protect endangered species and be enjoyed by tourists – than there are in cutting them down. “All we’re talking about here is the ideology of continuing to log native forests,” he says. There may be a need for a small proportion of native forest to be harvested for high-value uses such as furnishing and construction, but the days of sending the vast bulk of native timber off to be woodchipped are surely coming to an end. The Black Summer fires have changed the debate about native-forest logging, and there are worse fires to come as the planet heats up. From here on in – whether burnt or unburnt, old growth or regrowth – every patch of native forest matters.

Plantation and job losses raised at inquiry:

https://tatimes.com.au/timber-industry-future-probed-at-inquiry/

A public hearing of the House Standing Committee on Agriculture and Water Resources inquiry into timber supply chain constraints in the Australian plantation sector took place on October 23.

Chair of the Committee, Rick Wilson MP, said that the evidence they’ve heard so far is that accessing product is getting harder and harder.

“Obviously here particularly, in Tumut, we’ve got an issue with the fires, which has created a very dire short-term prospect,” he acknowledged.

… I guess the existing mills are getting fewer and fewer as the capital requirement gets bigger.”

[CEO of AKD Softwoods Shane Vicary] … “There will be 70 to 80 jobs lost sometime between now and probably June or July next year, when the harvest level reduces. That’s an outcome from the bushfires,” he said.

… Sawmills have had to get larger to scale up to reduce their processing costs and be able to compete with export pricing.”

“That’s what I would like to see—some form of mechanism that enables free market to work but ensures that we look after Australia’s domestic supply chain first and foremost, but that it doesn’t impinge on the rights of the commercial owner of the plantation.”

https://borderwatch.com.au/news/2020/11/06/call-for-royal-commission/

A ROYAL Commission into the sale of the South East forests is key to understanding the current log export issues, a parliamentary committee into the timber industry has heard.

The Legislative Council committee toured the region on a two-day trip this week as part of an inquiry on issues relating to the timber industry in the Limestone Coast.

At a hearing, veteran forestry consultant Jerry Leech said the committee was likely to conclude the problems underpinning the inquiry are with the clauses in the sale contract, which has never been made public.

“With the lease it is very obvious in my mind there are very obvious forestry management type flaws in the lease.

Doctors call for forest protection:

https://tasmps.greens.org.au/media-release/greens-welcome-doctors-call-end

The Greens welcome the call by 250 doctors and medical students to end native forest logging in lutruwita/Tasmania. It is a critical step in tackling the climate emergency, and protecting the health of Tasmanians.

Climate change is a health emergency – as has been made clear by the Australian Medical Association and eight national medical college bodies. The doctors who signed the letter to the Premier understand all too well how intrinsically linked the health of the planet and its people are.

Bushfires fan the flames of climate action:

https://time.com/5904762/australia-bushfires-climate-change-report/

The bushfires that scorched vast tracts of Australia in late 2019 and early 2020 were just a glimpse of what’s to come as global temperatures rise, a landmark report made public on Friday warned.

“Australia will have more hot days and fewer cool days. Sea levels are also projected to continue to rise,” the inquiry, led by a former chief of the Australian Defense Force, a former federal court judge and a climate policy expert, found. “Tropical cyclones are projected to decrease in number, but increase in intensity. Floods and bushfires are expected to become more frequent and more intense.”

But Morrison has argued that there is no direct link between Australia’s greenhouse gas emissions and the severity of the fires. “To suggest that with just 1.3% of global emissions, that Australia doing something differently, more or less, would have changed the fire outcome this season,” he told an Australian radio station,

That ignores the fact that Australia is one of the highest per capita emitters of carbon dioxide in the world, according to Climate Analytics, an advocacy group that tracks climate data. It is also one of the world’s leading exporters of coal. Accounting for fossil fuel exports increases the country’s footprint to about 5% of global emissions, equivalent to the world’s fifth largest emitter, according to Climate Analytics.

https://www.abc.net.au/news/2020-10-31/bushfire-royal-commission-final-report-a-stark-warning/12835096

The bushfire royal commission’s final report is a stark warning of a future marked by extreme weather impacts of climate change.

“Extreme weather has already become more frequent and intense because of climate change; further global warming over the next 20 to 30 years is inevitable,” they say.

“Catastrophic fire conditions may render traditional bushfire prediction models and firefighting techniques less effective,” they say.

The report notes there’s essentially nothing we can do about “locked in” warming set to occur over the next two decades.

But what happens after that is up to us. Warming “beyond the next 20 to 30 years is largely dependent on the trajectory of greenhouse gas emissions”, it says.

“The Bushfire Royal Commission has laid out the facts in no uncertain terms: climate change drove the Black Summer bushfires, and climate change is pushing us into a future of unprecedented bushfire severity,” said Greg Mullins, former commissioner of Fire and Rescue NSW and founder of Emergency Leaders for Climate Action.

https://www.aspistrategist.org.au/bushfire-royal-commission-warns-of-catastrophic-consequences-of-climate-change/

Australia has warmed by approximately 1.4°C since 1910.

The commission says that the 2019–20 fires started in Australia’s hottest and driest year on record. Much of the country that burned had already been impacted by drought and the forest fire danger index was the highest since national records began.

‘We heard from CSIRO that even under the low emissions scenario, which goes to net negative emissions, the climate does not return to a preindustrial or recent baseline type climate immediately’, the commission says. ‘It takes a very long time for that to occur, and would require CO2 to be removed from the atmosphere.’

https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2020/nov/01/born-in-the-ice-age-humankind-now-faces-the-age-of-fire-and-australia-is-on-the-frontline

As if neglect and omission in the face of the fire threat were not enough, Coalitionpoliticians and their apologists then hastily encouraged lies about the causes of the fires, declaring that they were started by arsonists and that greenies had prevented hazard-reduction burns. Yet these fires were overwhelmingly started by dry lightning in remote terrain, and hazard-reduction burning is constrained by a warming climate. The effort to stymie sensible policy reform after the fires was as pernicious as the failure to plan in advance of them.

For the beleaguered Coalition government, Covid seemed to provide the escape it wanted from climate politics.

The fires and the plague are both symptoms of something momentous that is unfolding on Earth: a concentration and acceleration of the impact of humans on nature. As the environmental scientists Inger Andersen and Johan Rockström argued in June: “Covid-19 is more than an illness. It is a symptom of the ailing health of our planet.”

Doing something about it means more than finding a vaccine; it means urgently addressing the causes of the climate emergency and the biodiversity crisis. It means understanding how dire the current rupture is in the long-term relationship between humans and nature.

https://architectureau.com/articles/bushfire-royal-commission-institue-response/

The Australian Institute of Architects has called on governments to act urgently following the public release of the bushfire royal commission report.

The Institute’s submission to the royal commission highlighted research that suggests up to a million existing houses in bushfire prone areas across Australia have little or no bushfire protection, with 2.2 million people living in high or extreme bushfire risk areas.

“This means we need to consider other approaches like the use of private and public shelters, such as they have done for decades in the United States as protection from hazards like wildfires and tornadoes,” Bell said.

The Institute also reiterated a call on the government to commit to net zero carbon emissions by 2030 …

Cambage said, “Resilience must include a commitment to net zero emissions in our buildings and responsiveness to our new climate reality because it is critically important to ensure that all rebuilding projects following natural disasters look to enhance the standard of our built environment.

… how fires mitigate climate change:

https://yubanet.com/scitech/smoke-cloud-pushed-into-the-stratosphere-by-last-winters-australian-wildfires-was-3-times-larger-than-anything-previously-recorded/

… a global team that has found that the smoke cloud pushed into the stratosphere by last winter’s Australian wildfires was three times larger than anything previously recorded.

The cloud, which measured 1,000 kilometres across, remained intact for three months, travelled 66,000 kilometres, and soared to a height of 35 kilometres above Earth. The findings were published in Communications Earth & Environment,

“We’re seeing records broken in terms of the impact on the atmosphere from these fires,” said Bourassa. “Knowing that they’re likely to strike more frequently and with more intensity due to climate change, we could end up with a pretty dramatically changed atmosphere.”

However, when aerosols—such as smoke from wildfires or sulphuric acid from a volcanic eruption—are forced up into the stratosphere, they can remain aloft for many months, blocking sunlight from passing through, which in turns changes the balance of the climate system.

https://wildfiretoday.com/2020/11/01/smoke-cloud-from-australias-wildfires-was-three-times-larger-than-anything-previously-recorded/

… money talks, and a $3.7 billion cost shouts:

https://www.financialstandard.com.au/news/climate-change-greater-threat-than-covid-report-176228777

Climate change is set to have a greater impact on the economy than the COVID-19 lockdowns, according to a new report from Deloitte Access Economics.

The report, A new choice: Australia’s climate for growth, found if climate change goes unchecked, Australia’s economy will be 6% smaller and have 880,000 fewer jobs by 2070.

However, in contrast, delivering net zero by 2050 and consistent with keeping global warming to 1.5 degrees Celsius, could add $680 billion and grow the economy by 2.6% in 2070.

“All of these numbers are sobering. By 2050 Australia will experience economic losses on par with COVID every single year if we don’t address climate change. That would compromise the economic future of all future generations of Australians,” Philip said.

“Whatever Australia does or doesn’t do, the global warming which has already taken place will hurt our lives and livelihoods. This cost is locked in – it is the cost of delay,” Philip said.

https://www.skynews.com.au/details/_6206257994001

https://reneweconomy.com.au/australia-faces-3-4-trillion-economic-bill-for-failure-to-act-on-climate-change-41179/

https://au.finance.yahoo.com/news/wrap-021020-204741533.html

https://www.abc.net.au/news/2020-11-02/australian-economy-lose-$3-trillion-climate-change-inaction/12837244

The Australian economy will lose more than if climate change is not addressed, according to a new report from Deloitte Access Economics.

https://thenewdaily.com.au/finance/finance-news/2020/11/02/climate-change-economy-deloitte/

… as the world continues to burn:

https://www.brusselstimes.com/news/eu-affairs/138624/over-400000-ha-of-forests-lost-to-fire-in-2019/

Over 400,000 ha. of forests were destroyed by fire in 2019, the worst year the world has known in recent times in terms of such disasters, the European Commission’s joint research centre noted in a report released on Friday.

The report, which provides an inventory of the devastation wrought by forest fires in Europe, the Middle East and North Africa, notes that a record number of protected natural areas were affected throughout the European Union in 2019.

“Part of the answer to ensure that this does not happen at such a devastating scale lies in protecting and managing the forests in a way to reduce their vulnerability to fires, allowing nature to also protect itself,” Sinkevicius stressed.

https://ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/detail/en/ip_20_1995

Droughts are altering forests:

https://cosmosmagazine.com/uncategorized/how-droughts-affect-forests/

High on the list of the threats forests face due to climate change is tree mortality following droughts, which are becoming longer and more severe.

This could trigger extensive ecosystem changes according to an international team of nearly 40 scientists, writing in the journal PNAS.

Overall, they found limited regrowth of key forest and woodland species. Just 21% of pre-drought trees grew back and 10% of forests and woodlands shifted to non-woody growth such as grasslands.

In more than two thirds of sites, dead trees were replaced mostly by shrubs, “pointing to important post-drought alterations of ecosystem structure and function”.

In 10% of sites there was no replacement by woody vegetation, which the authors say suggests “at least a transient loss of forest and woodland cover promoted by drought-related mortality”.

Tree species that resprout, such as cottonwoods (Populus spp), eucalypts (Eucalyptus spp) and oaks (Quercus spp), more successfully replaced themselves than trees that rely on seeds to propagate, such as pine trees (Pinus spp) and fir trees (Abies spp).

Ecosystems dominated by trees that favour moist conditions, for instance, showed shifts towards more drought tolerant plants. … Corymbia calophylla superseding Eucalyptus marginate in Australia.

“The ultimate temporal persistence of such changes remains unknown,” they write, “but, given the key role of biological legacies in long-term ecological succession, this emerging picture of post-drought ecological trajectories highlights the potential for major ecosystem reorganisation in the coming decades.”

https://phys.org/news/2020-11-summer-one-tenth-central-european-forests.html

The result: Trees suffered most in warm, dry regions, where it was even hotter and drier than the long-term average, especially if they tended to be small to medium-sized and stood on steep terrain and shallow soils. In future, such locations and tree characteristics can thus be classified as risk factors for drought damage

In the summer of 2018, central Europe experienced its most extreme period of drought and heat wave since measurements began. It has had a greater impact on forests than any other dry spell in the last 60 years. “If such events occur more frequently, beech and spruce will probably have difficulty surviving in the longer term in the regions affected in 2018,” says study leader Niklaus Zimmermann

We are super spreaders:

https://inews.co.uk/news/environment/ash-dieback-grim-toll-english-forests-national-trust-750671

Ash dieback is devastating forests across England, with the National Trust this week warning it will have to fell thousands of dead trees this winter for public safety.

Ash trees make up about 20 per cent of woodland in Britain, but up to 90 per cent of these trees could be lost in the next 30 years to the disease. The fungal disease, which arrived in Europe from Asia about 30 years ago, causes the leaves of a tree to drop off and the crown to die back, eventually causing the death of the tree.

The good news, he said, is that older Ash trees appear to be more resilient to the disease, with felling largely confined to younger trees planted in the 1990s.

https://www.miragenews.com/emerald-ash-borer-puts-trees-on-path-to-functional-extinction/

WEST LAFAYETTE, Ind. —Since the emerald ash borer’s introduction to the United States at the beginning of the 21st century, forest ecologists and government officials have striven to stem its destruction of ash forests. Despite those efforts, the invasive pest may be winning the war.

Mining 16 years of U.S. Forestry Service Forest Inventory Analysis data for 960 counties, Purdue University professor Songlin Fei has shown that in impacted areas, young trees are dying before they can reach their reproductive stages. Unable to compete with larger trees or resist the emerald ash borer, American ash trees may be doomed to functional extinction.

The Penan still battling to save their dwindling forests:

https://www.ucanews.com/news/malaysias-indigenous-people-seek-to-protect-forests/90124#

Intensive forest clearing has caused an ecological disaster in the Malaysian state of Sarawak where both numerous critically endangered species and indigenous ways of life are at risk of disappearing for good unless all large-scale deforestation ceases in already badly fragmented and much-thinned forests.

“[Further] logging will destroy our forests,” Komeok Joe, a leader of an indigenous semi-nomadic ethnic group known as the Penan, has warned in an interview with Al Jazeera.

“It will destroy our rivers and medicines and prevent us from satisfying all of our needs in the forests on which we depend for our lives. We Penan communities reject any logging activities in our Baram territory,” he added.

https://www.sustainability-times.com/environmental-protection/indigenous-people-on-borneo-seek-to-save-their-forests-from-loggers/

“A century ago, most of Borneo was covered in forest. But the region has lost over half of its forests, and a third of these have disappeared in just the last three decades,” the World Wide Fund for Nature (WWF) explains.

“Only half of Borneo’s forest cover remains today, down from 75 per cent in the mid-1980s. With a current deforestation rate of 1.3 million hectares per year, only peat and montane forests would survive in the coming years,” the WWF warns.

We know what to do to save ourselves, and some have committed to do it (not Trump or Morrison) , but its not happening fast enough:

https://climatenewsnetwork.net/rewilded-farmland-can-save-money-%e2%88%92-and-the-earth/

Global salvation requires the world’s nations to do simply what they have already undertaken to do: restore 15% of cultivated land to natural forest, grassland, shrubland, wetland and desert ecosystem.

If such restoration happened in the highest priority zones, then almost two-thirds of the wild things now threatened with imminent extinction could survive.

And the restored wilderness that would protect them would also start absorbing atmospheric carbon at an accelerating rate: it could sequester an estimated 229 billion tonnes of the greenhouse gas carbon dioxide (CO2). This is almost a third of all the CO2 spilled into the atmosphere by coal, oil and gas combustion in the last 200 years.

All that would be possible if the world’s nations delivered on vows made 10 years ago in Japan, to restore 15% of ecosystems worldwide. If the 196 nations that signed up went further, and restored a carefully chosen 30%, they could save more than 70% of the million or so species sliding towards extinction, and absorb 465 billion tonnes of CO2: almost half of all the extra atmospheric carbon loaded into the atmosphere by human societies since the Industrial Revolution.

Researchers have repeatedly argued that simply planting more trees could have a dramatic impact on global heating; that a switch towards a plant-based diet could help stem biodiversity loss and reduce emissions; and that

without concerted global action, precious ecosystems could collapse altogether read more

Share

Environment groups rally across NSW to urge parliament to maintain forest protections

From NEFA [North East Forest Alliance]:

The NSW Government’s Upper House will debate legislation next week that would “remove most of the hard won gains made over the past 25 years”. Far from arresting the decline in Koala numbers, changes to the LLS Act will see Koalas extinct in NSW before 2050.

NEFA and other environment groups [incl. the CEC] across the state are holding coordinated protests today to try and push MPs to block the bill, which is expected to be voted on in the Upper House on November 11. Protests will happen in Coffs Harbour, Grafton, Kempsey, Port Macquarie, Sydney, Taree and Tweed Heads.

“The Local Land Services Amendment (Miscellaneous) Bill 2020 introduced into parliament on 14 October represents the Liberal Party’s total capitulation to the loggers and developers at the behest of the National Party”, NEFA spokesperson Dailan Pughsaid.

“These proposed changes are clearly intended to make the Koala SEPP ineffective and remove most of the hard won gains made over the past 25 years.

“This is a despicable act from a Government hell-bent on halving our rapidly diminishing populations of Koalas, not doubling them.” Mr. Pugh said.

Grafton

“Chris Gulaptis spoke out against planning protections for Koalas on social media last month, supporting Developers instead. Not good enough!” Naomi Shine from the Lismore Environment Centre said.

Tweed Heads

“Geoff Provest has been boasting to local environment groups about how much he cares about koalas and yet he voted for the Bill in the lower house. We are calling on him to take real action for Koalas and call for his upper house counterparts to block this bill.” Naomi Shine from the Lismore Environment Centre said.

Taree

At a silent vigil outside Lesley Williams office in Port Macquarie, Susie Russell from NEFA said “Lesley Williams left the National Party, appalled at their behaviour. We’re appalled at hers, she has voted for the National Party’s anti-Koala legislation. Koalas on private land will continue to die, with no requirements to protect them or their habitat and logging and land clearing given the green light.”

“The empathy of the NSW Government for Koalas is only as deep as the ink in the newsprint they seek to generate with their gestures of concern, meanwhile the bulldozers are knocking over the Koala trees.”

Coffs Harbour

Community members and environmental groups gathering outside Gurmesh Singh’s MP’s Coffs Harbour office to bring attention to Mr Singh’s lack of concern for the survival of koalas in the wild after he voted to weaken the protection of koala habitat that is essential for the survival of this iconic species.

Mr Singhs electorate of Coffs Harbour is one of the few forested areas on the east coast of NSW with significant koala populations that survived the 19/20 bushfires.

Kempsey

Bellingen Community Members gather outside Melinda Pavey MP’s Office to show the shock and grave concern about the “Removal of Bellingen Shire Koala Management Plan” as part of the immediate impact of a sweeping loss of protections for Koalas contained within the Local Land Services Amendment Miscellaneous Bill and the community appeals to Minister Pavey to have our Shire Koala Management Plan Restored

Share

Urgent: The Senate Vote will be the final nail in the coffin for our Native Forests and Koalas.

The Local Land Services Amendment (Miscellaneous) Bill 2020 is likely to be voted on in the Upper House on 11th November.

This bill will be the final nail in the coffin for our Native Forests and Koalas.

There are three members who could change the outcome if we contact them now. They need to know we don’t accept them destroying native forests and extincting Koalas!

Tell them

1. The requirement that core Koala habitat identified in Koala Plans Of Management (POMs) be identified as State Sensitive Regulated Land under the Local Land Services Act, with current protections from logging and broadscale clearing to be maintained.

2. Retain the ability of Councils to prohibit, or require consent for, logging and clearing in environmental zones. read more

Share

Gutting of Koala SEPP, Changes To The NSW Local Land Services (LLS) Act, Update From NEFA

From NEFA [North East Forest Alliance]:

The changes to the LLS Act passed by the NSW Lower House will go to the Upper House in November. So there is still time to lobby Upper House MPs to vote it down – such as Catherine Cusack, Ben Franklin (who seems to have already sold his soul), and Fred Nile.

It is still worth holding Lower House MPs such a Geoff Provest and Leslie Williams to account.

For those in Bellingen, it is extraordinary that of the 6 LGAs with 6900 ha of core Koala Habitat identified as Environmentally Sensitive Land, only Bellingen’s 900ha is to be stripped of its protection.

If passed the Local Land Services Amendment (Miscellaneous) Bill 2020 will:

  • stop core Koala habitat identified in draft and future council Koala Plans of Management from being included as Sensitive Regulated Land, and thereby require approval for broadscale clearing, as well as removing prohibition on logging.
  • allow up to 6,000 ha of core Koala habitat identified as Sensitive Regulated Land in the Ballina, Coffs Harbour, Kempsey, Lismore and Port Stephens LGAs to remain, though remove 900 ha of core Koala habitat identified in the Bellingen LGA
  • stop Councils being able to include core Koala habitat in environmental protection zones: ”e-zones will not be created in relation to any koala plans of management” Ben Franklin
  • create the concept of ‘allowable activity land’, which is land that at some time has been rezoned from rural zoning to environmental zoning, and permits clearing for ‘allowable activities’ (including buffers) without approval in these E zones (i.e. allowable activities include construction timber, farm forestry, gravel pits, grazing, powerlines, water and gas pipelines, fire breaks, fences, roads, tracks, sheds, tanks, dams, stockyards, bores, pumps, water points or windmills).
  • prevent local environment plans from requiring development consent for Private Native Forestry (PNF)
  • double the duration allowed for PNF plans from 15 years to 30 years.

The EDO have an excellent assessment of the changes: https://www.edo.org.au/publication/local-land-services-amendment-miscellaneous-bill-2020-summary-of-key-concerns/ read more

Share

Thunberg and Attenborough were at the Regent!

“The story of teenage climate activist Greta Thunberg is told through compelling, never-before-seen footage in this intimate documentary from Swedish director Nathan Grossman. Starting with her one-person school strike for climate action outside the Swedish Parliament, Grossman follows Greta — a shy student with Asperger’s — in her rise to prominence and her galvanizing global impact as she sparks school strikes around the world. The film culminates with her extraordinary wind-powered voyage across the Atlantic Ocean to speak at the UN Climate Action Summit in New York City.”

Friday, October 16th 1:00 PM Saturday, October 17th

4:30 PM read more

Share

Cutting Down Native Forests on Private Land Draft Codes of Practice

The Draft Private Native Forestry Code of Practice have been open for public submissions.

We have read the Draft Codes of Practice, and highlighted the bits of the document for you to read quickly, to focus and save time.

It is ‘A permission-booklet for ecologically significant native forests destruction on privately held land.’

See the highlighted Draft Code-of-Practice for Logging Native Forests on Privately Owned Land for Northern-NSW. Download

For further information from the EDO, see https://bit.ly/3aJO7qs

For information about the codes from Local Land Services, see https://bit.ly/2Yc3tBn

For a fact sheet from Local Land Services, see https://bit.ly/2SihXM7

Share

The UN 2020 Fossil Fuel Production Gap Report

The world is ‘doubling down’ on fossil fuels despite the climate crisis.

“Between 2020 and 2030, global coal, oil, and gas production would have to decline annually by 11%, 4%, and 3%, respectively, to be consistent with a 1.5°C pathway. But governments’ plans and projections indicate an average 2% annual increase for each fuel.

“Continued production of fossil fuels at current levels, let alone the increases envisioned by governments, is at odds with a climate-safe future. Coal, oil, and gas account for over three-fourths of global greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions, including 90% of carbon dioxide emissions and roughly a third of methane emissions.

“Fossil fuel interests — which represent a large and concentrated political and economic force — often actively counter or resist bold climate action. When governments are dependent on fossil fuels, this “carbon entanglement” can stand in the way of climate policy progress. read more

Share

Big Scrub Landcare online event focused on the bushfires in and around Nightcap National Park and their impact on our Gondwana and lowland subtropical rainforests in north east NSW:

 

‘Saving our Rainforests from Fire’ – Expert panel discussion: 

Big Scrub Landcare invited the community to listen to experts who were involved in fighting the fires and assessing their impacts on the Nightcap discuss these critically important issues in two online panel discussions, facilitated by Kerry O’Brien and Mick O’Regan.

This free online event focused on the bushfires in and around Nightcap National Park and their impact on our Gondwana and lowland subtropical rainforests in north east NSW.

View the event here: https://www.bigscrubrainforest.org/panel-discussions/

PANEL 1  focused on:

• What were the impacts of the major bushfire event of 2019/2020 on our rainforests and their threatened species in Nightcap National Park and nearby areas? read more

Share

NEFA are proposing that 6,988ha of public land south-west of Casino in north-east NSW be created as the Sandy Creek Koala Park

The genesis of this proposal was the finding of exceptional densities of Koalas at a number of localities and widespread Koala usage. The Koalas appeared to be increasing as the forests recovered from past logging, with good future prospects if the forest was allowed to age and provide increasing resources over time.

This proposal is about stopping ongoing degradation and restoring what has been lost. Recovering Koalas, another 39 threatened species, inadequately reserved Richmond River lowland forests, forest carbon carrying capacity, and stream flows. It is about honouring the community’s wishes and aspirations.

From NEFA findings it is apparent that remnant forests with numbers of mature Small-fruited Grey Gums, Coastal Grey Box, Forest Red Gum and/or Slaty Red Gum, on and adjoining the Richmond River floodplain, provide habitat that is highly significant to maintenance of the regional Koala population, along with a variety of other threatened species and ecosystems. read more

Share

Day of Action to Save our Koalas

On a Day of Action to Save our Koalas, August 16th, individuals and community groups across NSW organised small ‘pop-up protests’ and virtual actions to attempt to cause nsw.gov to act now to implement the recomendations of the NSW Govt. Inquiry Report: ‘Koala Populations and Habitat in New South Wales’.

Tweed representatives took the day of action to the office of Geoff Provest, MP, member for Tweed. Hear what they have to say >

Share

Local National Parks Have Been Directed To Implement Tourism

National Parks, directed by nsw.gov, for economic reasons, are to increase national park use tourism, especially here in the Caldera.

Eg is a 4 day 45km walking trail starting at Mt Jerusalem to Minyon Falls. Marketed to the early adopters.

The DA for the day 1 part of the track (‘Unicorn Falls’) closed for comments with 50 submissions.

To what degree will areas be protected from tourism?

Will the DA assessments ignore the impact on existing amenity and on ecological protection concerns?

unicorn-falls-master-plan-200196-2Download unicorn-falls-master-plan-200196-2-1Download
Share

Draft State Strategic Plan for Crown Land

Government has prioritised the commercialisation of Crown Lands and misses both The Ecological Importance of Crown Lands and the need to move towards First Nations stewardship and co-management.

Crown Land is our land, it belongs to the people of NSW and should be managed in the way we believe is appropriate.

Download the document here: State Strategic Plan – A Vision for Crown LandDownload

We have highlighted the interesting bits for clarity and speed of reading.

Note within the Draft Plan, the noble sounding ‘Work with Aboriginal comunities to realise the potential of their land rights” is code language for gaining contracted economic access to newly Aboriginal Titled Crown Lands. In this regard the Plan For Crown Lands is a tool for further aboriginal dispossession, just when they got some of their land back again.

Make an Online Submission here: Crown Land online submission tool … read more

Share

Again, NO Byrrill Creek Dam

Dear Friends of the Environment.

The NSW Natural Resources Commission (NRC) is undertaking a Review, including submissions from the public, of the existing Tweed Water Sharing Plan (WSP) which expires next year. Currently there is a Clause 48 (1) that prohibits the building of a dam at Byrrill Creek.

10 years ago Save Byrrill Creek fought a long campaign to have this prohibition upheld, especially when councillors chose Byrrill Creek Dam as their primary Water Augmentation. Luckily, with a new more environmentally aware Council elected, in Oct 2011 this was rescinded, and in May 2012 the Council placed a 20-year Moratorium on any dam proposal at Byrrill Creek. Some Councillors to this day still want to dam Byrrill Creek.

There are also other important environmental issues in the Water Sharing Plan that could be covered.

It is vital to keep the prohibition within the New Tweed Water Sharing Plan, so we need lots of people to write a submission to the NRC (by 5 July) and also to Council. Council are also making a submission and are holding an extraordinary meeting on the 2nd July to discuss this.

You can send a copy of your NRC Submission to the Council but 

it must be there by 30th June prior to their meeting. read more

Share

TSC Towards Zero Waste Strategy Proposed, TSC Asks Your Feedback

Council has prepared a draft Towards Zero Waste policy and is seeking feedback on or before Tuesday 21 July 2020.

The CEC would like to encourage public endorsement and adoption by Council.

The towards zero waste concept means designing and managing products to reduce the volume of waste and materials, to conserve and recover all materials where possible, and to send waste to landfill as a last resort.

The draft policy has been developed to guide Council on future strategies, actions and targets towards zero waste practices.

Make a submission at www.yoursaytweed.com.au/zerowaste .

To download the TSC Draft Integrated Waste Management Strategy, click this:Download

.

Share

THE NOBBYS CREEK WATER EXTRACTION D.A. HAS BEEN FORMALLY REJECTED BY COUNCIL – HURRAH

From Nimbin EC: “There’s a bit of reading here, but it is well worth it ………………………………………

You will recall that Council had deemed the Nobbys Creek water extraction expansion application would be refused, so Appleby lodged an appeal in the Land and Environment Court. As part of the court process, Council was required to formally assess the application. Thanks to you, wonderful supporters, 297 objections were received and formed part of the assessment. (One submission was in support.)

The reasons have been extracted here:

The application has not adequately established that the commercial extraction of groundwater for water bottling is a sustainable use of this resource, or that it will not have an adverse impact on natural water systems or the potential agricultural use of the land, the environment, or other groundwater or surface users,

and that it has
– not adequately established that the commercial extraction of groundwater for water bottling is a sustainable use of this resource, or that it will not have an adverse impact on the environment, agricultural uses, or other groundwater or surface users, or that it maintains the rural landscape character of the land,
– not adequately established that the commercial extraction of groundwater for water bottling will not have an adverse impact on natural water systems or the potential agricultural use of the land in regard to the sustainable use of this resource.
– not adequately established that the commercial extraction of groundwater for water bottling is a sustainable use of this resource, or that it will not impact on the environment, agricultural uses, or other groundwater or surface users.
– not adequately established that the commercial extraction of groundwater for water bottling is a sustainable use of this resource, or that it will not impact on the environment, agricultural uses, or other groundwater or surface users.
– not adequately established that the commercial extraction of groundwater for water bottling will not impact on the environment, agricultural uses, or other groundwater or surface users, and that the rural character and amenity of the area will not be adversely affected.
– not adequately established that the commercial extraction of groundwater for water bottling is a sustainable use of this resource, or that it will not impact on the environment, agricultural uses, or other groundwater or surface users, and that the rural character and amenity of the area will not be adversely affected or that the rural road is suitable for the use.
– not adequately established that the commercial extraction of groundwater for water bottling is a sustainable use of this resource, or that it will not impact on the environment, agricultural uses, or other groundwater or surface users, and that the rural character and amenity of the area will not be adversely affected or that the rural road is suitable for the use.
– not adequately established that the commercial extraction of groundwater for water bottling is a sustainable use of this resource, or that it will not impact on the environment, agricultural uses, or other groundwater or surface users, and that the rural character and amenity of the area will not be adversely affected or that the rural road is suitable for the use.
– in terms of public interest, the application has not obtained appropriate owners consent for the use of the unlawful structures within the road reserve, and that
– the application will not result in any public benefit or additional employment and so is not in the public interest to provide use of public road reserve.

Thank you to all those that lodged submissions. Cheers!

====================

Last night, Development Application DA19/0888 for alterations and additions to an existing water bottling facility at No. 24 Bryens Road Nobbys Creek, was REFUSED by a majority vote of Council.
VOTE FOR – Cr Katie Milne (Mayor), Cr Chris Cherry (Deputy Mayor), Cr Reece Byrnes, C Ron Cooper, Cr James Owen
VOTE AGAINST – Cr Pryce Allsop, Cr Warren Polglase.

Share

NCC, AFCA to ARENA Bioenergy Roadmap: “Exclude forest derived biomass … FDB is not a credible or desirable energy source or route out of fossil fuel dependence.”

The Nature Conservation Council and the Australian Forest and Climate Alliance have made the following joint submission to the ARENA Bioenergy Roadmap: 

“Exclude forest derived biomass.” 

FDB is not a credible or desirable energy source or route out of fossil fuel dependence. 

We call on ARENA to contribute to responsible action on the climate crisis by ruling out forest derived bioenergy (FDB) or biomass. 

FDB is: 

  • more emissive than coal at the point of combustion
  • not carbon neutral, (within time frames identified by the IPCC to reduce atmospheric carbon, if ever)
  • not clean
  • harmful to people and biodiversity

The best way to deploy native forests to tackle climate change is to protect and restore them to slow emissions and increase the removal of carbon dioxide (CO2) from the atmosphere.

In 2013, the Australian Government explained their policy on native forest bioenergy in their publishedresponse to the Climate Change Authority’s Renewable Energy Target (RET) Review: read more

Share

TSC: Dear Community Member, …

I write to advise you that the Tweed Local Environmental Plan 2014 Amendment No. 28 – to remove the enabling ‘Clause 7.15 Water Bottling Facilities’ – has been legally made, effective Friday 29 May 2020.

The outcome of this amendment is that water bottling facilities are now a prohibited land use in the RU2 Rural Landscape Zone in the Tweed.  Existing approved water bottling facilities are allowed to continue to operate legally, but no new operations on new parcels of land are allowed.

Thank you for your interest in this issue and for taking the time to provide a submission during the public exhibition of the planning proposal. 

To view the final LEP Amendment go to https://legislation.nsw.gov.au/EPIs/2020-234.pdf read more

Share

CSG Alert: Reject gas giant Santos’s 850-well coal seam gas field in the Pilliga forests wilderness

The NSW Government has recommended approval of an 850-well coal seam gas field in the Pilliga forest wilderness and farmland near Narrabri.

The Pilliga is the largest temperate forest we have left in the state. Turning it into an industrial gas field will poison groundwater, carve up the forest with roads and pipelines, endanger koalas and other threatened species, and increase the risk of wildfires.

Before this project gets the green light, it must be approved by the Independent Planning Commission (IPC). 

Tell the Independent Planning Commission to reject gas giant Santos’s 850-well coal seam gas field in the Pilliga forests wilderness near Narrabri. Sign this:

https://www.nature.org.au/get-involved/take-action/save-the-pilliga-from-csg/

PETITION

To the Independent Planning Commission,

We call on you to oppose Santos’s Narrabri coal seam gas field near Narrabri as it will: read more

Share

Art Auction – “Artists for Climate Online”

Zoom in, to raise funds for the Climate Council! It’s an online auction of art items contributed by fabulous artists from Tweed and Byron Shires. All proceeds will go to The Climate Council. Barry Firth is raising funds for the Climate Council, after joining “Tassie Trek 2020”, a week-long trip through the Tarkine Wilderness, that is now going to happen in year 2021.

Register now for the online auction on June 26 @ 6pm:  barry.firth@sov.net.au

Look at this wonderful art! 

Link to catalogue: https://www.dropbox.com/s/s6cpm6dfwky7try/Catalogue%20AfC.pdf?dl=0

Please join in and do your bit to support the Climate Council. 

More details on Facebook page:  https://www.facebook.com/ArtistsForClimate/ read more

Share

To: Department of Planning Industry & Environment. Re: Koala Habitat Protection SEPP

The new koala protection guidelines rely heavily on the “Koala Development Application Map”. However, land clearing for “logging operations” on private lands” are exempt from these guidelines, as these operations do not normally require DA approval.  

For logging on private lands Koala protection is supposed to be based on local “Comprehensive Koala Plans of Management” (KPoM). 

HOWEVER – since 1995 only 6 Council KPoMs have been approved and only 3 of them contained Core Koala Habitat.  

This is clearly a giant hole in the proposed koala protection policy.

What measures are in place to fast-track Council KPoMs to align with the introduction of these new “Koala Protection Laws”? 

In 2017 the EDO warned that new Native Vegetation Codes could allow rural land clearing of hundreds of hectares at a time without a DA and without reference to the Koala SEPP.  They recommended that koala mapping be in place =&0=& the new land clearing system commenced.  The EDO also recommended that the new Koala SEPP must also apply to rural land-clearing proposals that exceed the Code limits to ensure these land clearing proposals are assessed by the new “Native Vegetation Panel”.  (EDO NSW Jan 2017)

However – a recent report has revealed a startling increase in levels of land-clearing in NSW since 2017.  In 2018/19 37,000 ha of clearing was approved – =&1=&  Between 2017/18 – 60% of clearing was ‘unexplained’.

Much of this clearing was in contravention of new land clearing regulations but the lack of a robust Koala SEPP (with the caveats suggested by the EDO) was clearly a missing layer of protection and may have prevented such devastating habitat loss.

When we add the damage this intense land clearing has done to the damage wrought by recent extreme fires in NSW we are looking at a catastrophic outcome for wildlife habitat and koala habitat.

This is the calamitous environment in which the new Koala Protection SEPP must work.

Its stated intent remains as:

The aim of the SEPP … will continue to be to protect koala habitat to ensure a permanent free-living population over the present range and reverse the current trend of koala population decline. 

If there is =&2=&of achieving this in NSW it is absolutely imperative that:

The NSW Government fast track shire-wide Koala Plans of Management that comprehensively identify core Koala Habitat.  They must assist with the mapping of this habitat and have a =&3=&for achieving this across all the relevant shires in NSW

Development Applications must be required for all logging and clearing of likely koala habitat identified in the “Koala Development Application Map”

This requirement must be put in place =&4=&  It must remain in place until Councils Comprehensive Koala Plans of Management are in place.

The development approval process =&5=&important koala habitat to be offset or cleared in exchange for money as the BAM (Biodiversity Assessment Method) allows.  The approval process must achieve the aims of protecting resident koala populations and reversing population decline.

Koalas in NSW were in serious trouble even before these devastating fires and extreme land clearing.  North East NSW saw 50% population declines over the last 20 years primarily due to land clearing and logging.  Since the fires we have =&6=&

The classification of the Koala as “Vulnerable” may well need to be revised to “Critically Endangered” particularly in areas of high impact.  Koala expert Steve Phillips has estimated the once viable Port Macquarie population will be extinct within 20-50 years.  Many other species are set to follow this path as fires increase in frequency and intensity and other impacts of climate change take hold – intensified drought, heat and flooding rains will also take their toll on native habitat.

NSW plans for “intensive logging” of 142,000 ha of State Forest is =&7=&and in the current circumstances will cause it to fail entirely.   Intensive logging has replaced “tree selection”.  Every single tree is clear-felled except for occasional clumps which cannot harbour any viable wildlife populations.  Extinction of koalas, arboreal animals and others is almost guaranteed.

Although only the Koala Protection SEPP is currently under review it seems to be imperative that the department considers this policy in relation to other policies it has the power to influence.   The situation has evolved dramatically since decisions were made on land clearing and land clearing laws in NSW.  Surely there is now an urgency to revisit the policies and decisions that will impact the success of this new Koala SEPP and the survival of koalas in the wild in NSW for generations to come?

Share

Ancient trees cut down

The government’s own logging corporation has been caught red-handed cutting down giant trees that were earmarked for protection in Wild Cattle Creek State Forest near Coffs Harbour. 

This outrageous destruction shows NSW Forestry Corporation can’t be trusted to obey already weak forest protection laws. It’s clear we need to end native forest logging. 

This is not the first time Forestry Corporation has been busted breaking the rules but this time it is different. The Environment Protection Agency (EPA), which usually lets Forestry Corp off with a slap on the wrist, has issued the first stop-work order in 20 years. That means logging in Wild Cattle Creek has stopped, at least for the time being. And if the EPA decides to prosecute, Forestry Corp could be fined up to $5 million. It’s that serious. read more

Share

Feeding Forests Into Furnaces To Boil Water To Turn A Turbine To Make Electricity To Use Momentarily And Then It Is Gone

Stop the pollution of the air, it is horrible, stop it.

And stop burning “biofuel” for goodness sake.

“Bio-Fuel”: Feeding Forests Into Furnaces To Make Electricity.

“Bio-Fuel” is burned in furnaces and the pollution released into the air.

They lie that biofuel is an ‘ecologically sustainable’ furnace fuel.

“Bio-Fuel” is a fraud, a lie, “Bio-Fuel” is a fraudulent, EU Regulations manipulating, money making op.

“Bio-Fuel” is killing, by ‘harvesting’, the last of the carbon capture and storage organisms, the trees.

“Bio-Fuel” is destroying the forests which is the very location of the ecology, the place in which the ecology exists.

“Bio-Fuel” is killing The Ecology. read more

Share

Caldera Environment Centre submission to Tweed Shire Council on the Draft Climate Change Policy – Net Zero 2030

The Caldera Environment Centre (CEC) strongly supports the Draft Climate Change Policy – Net Zero 2030. This draft policy builds on the framework of the Tweed Shire Council Community Strategic Plan 2017-2027 – in particular regarding its goals of decreasing the carbon footprint of the Tweed Shire, progressing toward 100% self sufficiency in renewable energy and preparing for climate change through adaptation and mitigation. 

In the face of the predicted dramatic impacts of climate change (see the 2018 report of the United Nations Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change https://www.ipcc.ch/sr15/chapter/spm/) Council clearly has responsibility to work both within its own structures and within the community to prepare to manage this unprecedented level of forthcoming change and to take a precautionary approach. Some of these changes are already observable. The changes predicted include hotter temperatures and for longer periods of time, increased frequency and intensity of bushfires, more storms and floods, decreased predictability and reliability of rainfall and increased drought, rise in sea levels and further loss of already fast decreasing biodiversity levels (current threat involves over a million species). These changes will definitely impact local community health, agriculture and other economic spheres (e.g. tourism), emergency response capability, and management of the increasing threat to the biodiversity and integrity of the natural environment.  read more

Share

The Million Jobs Plan

Beyond Zero Emissions

https://bze.org.au/the-million-jobs-plan/

The Million Jobs Plan is the framework to restore our economy. We’ve mapped out how we can rebuild our nation through practical projects that can restore our economy, modernise our industry, reskill our workforce and deliver a bright and secure economic future.

We’ve identified seven key sectors across our economy where strategic investment over the next five years would have the most impact and create the most jobs, including

  • Energy
  • Building
  • Manufacturing
  • Transport
  • Recycling
  • Land Use
  • Training

Jobs will be distributed around Australia, including in cities and regions already under pressure from the closure of traditional heavy industry and manufacturing, historical droughts and fires, and high unemployment. read more

Share

Review of Native vegetation clearing in NSW (Natural Resources Commission, NRC)

The level of clearing confirmed by expert report shows that rather than helping the environment our laws are now operating to put greater stress on native landscapes that are already suffering the impacts of climate change, drought and bushfires.  Instead of building resilience and ensuring healthy and productive country, our laws are degrading the land.

It is extremely disappointing that the general public and NFP environmental groups like NEFA were not included in the review process.  The review conducted by the NRC was due to broadscale land clearing exceeding acceptable rates, and in turn, triggering the legal requirement for a review according to the Vegetation Laws of 2016. However, the review’s existence and its results were not made public, it had to be sought and released by members of the media.

The data in this report is truly alarming.  

It shows clearing rates have increased by almost 13 times.  

Biodiversity in 9 of 11 regions is now at risk.

Unexplained clearing has risen to a point that the NRC concludes is “a major risk” and that “compliance rates are inadequate”

The relaxation of rules around “offset areas” to compensate for land clearing has resulted in a dismally inadequate result.  The area that is required to be managed under conservation agreements falls far short of the minimum – by 33,743 hectares!

The EDO NSW had warned (in 2016) of fatal flaws in the new native vegetation laws, and tragically, their concerns are now apparent in what is a blatant failure of regulatory policy.

In 2017 the new native vegetation laws were established with a new approach to land clearing that replaced established guidelines with “self-assessment” and more flexible “biodiversity offsets”.

This approach relied heavily on regulatory mapping to determine the basis for clearing of native vegetation.  It also required the establishment of a “native vegetation panel” of ecological experts to assess suitability of applications for vegetation clearing.   Another layer of protection against unfettered clearing was the Biodiversity Conservation Act and its facility to declare protected areas of “Outstanding Biodiversity Value” AOBV.  

After two years it is now apparent =&0=&There is no complete “regulatory map”, no evidence of a Native Vegetation Panel and no process for declaring an ABOV.

Current mapping has not yet classified the vast majority of lands in NSW into areas of classified regulation.  Landholders are expected to “self-categorise” their landholdings without the necessary skills to identify ecological communities or sensitive biodiversity.  Furthermore – it is not in their economic interest to assess their land is Category 1 (exempt from land clearing).

Under the new laws areas that have been mapped and regulated with a code are supposed to be monitored by a Native Vegetation Panel.  This independent panel must consider the environmental, social and economic impacts of any proposed land clearing and refuse anything that has serious irreversible impacts on biodiversity values.  However, the EDO has found that =&1=&applications have been made to the panel since the scheme began!

The EDO concludes that we are left with a situation where all the significant clearing now occurring in NSW is happening under a self-assessable Code or allowable activity. 

Without the oversight of a Panel we cannot know whether land of high conservation value, threatened species or ecological communities is being cleared indiscriminately.  The new LLS act contains mechanisms for assessment and approval but no such mechanisms appear to have been put in place!

The declaration of areas as ‘AOBV’ was intended to protect critical habitats containing irreplaceable biodiversity important to NSW, Australia or the world.  In such areas code-based clearing would be prohibited and private land conservation agreements would be put in place.  To date the EDO has not found=&2=&Previously protected communities like the Wollemi Pine and the Little Penguin remain without protection=&3=&under the new laws.

The picture that emerges for our native environment is a man-made disaster.  This is in addition to the horror of recent fires and severe drought.  In such circumstances the laws that protect our native environments are of extreme importance.  It is appalling to see these laws stripped of their potency and operating with only a fraction of their essential mechanisms at a time when we need them most urgently!  

It is equally appalling to read the governments response to this report which is perfunctory at best showing no grasp of the extent of this policy failure and the consequences we have already witnessed.  The NSW governments’ published response merely “notes” the points concerning mapping and ABOVs.  It agrees only “in principle” to consider reviewing aspects of the law that are clearly failing.  It does not commit to independent scrutiny or public transparency but only to in-house reviews.  There is no intent to “fix” or “reform” anything as a result.

The monumental failures outlined by the NRC and explained by the EDO require the wholesale rewriting of land clearing laws in NSW.  In light of natural disasters and ongoing impacts of climate change it is more important than ever that these laws fulfil the purpose of conserving landscapes and building environmental resilience.

Share

ACTIVE HOPE AND RESILIENCE IN A TIME OF CRISIS

A community event held by Extinction Rebellion Tweed Valley.

We are living through difficult times that have only gotten harder the last six months as we face regular new waves of social and environmental crises. In this time we are witnessing immense growing social injustices and the sixth mass extinction of life on Earth. Many of us feel called to act, and while political engagement is crucial, many are also asking, how do we sustain ourselves on this journey? How do we live with the fear, heartbreak and anger? How do we create a regenerative culture from within as we move toward a life-sustaining culture and society? How can we recognise the extent of the solutions needed if we cannot fully feel the depth of our despair? read more

Share

NCC: Stop logging the previously protected old-growth and high-conservation-value public forests.

>15,000 hectares of NSW previously protected old-growth and high-conservation-value public forests are to be logged.

More than 29,000 hectares of previously protected old-growth forests on private land have already been opened up to logging in recent years.

These rare and important forests have been protected for almost 20 years. They store huge amounts of carbon and provide irreplaceable habitat for many threatened species, including koalas, gliders, quolls, frogs and owls.

Add your voice to the call to ‘Save Our Old-Growth Forests‘.

.

.

Share

GONDWANA BURNING – Frontline Films [David Bradbury] > 9 Minute Pre Film Preview

Dear Invitee.

David has asked our [CEC] attention and interest, he has provided the 9 minute Pre Film Preview and requested feedback regarding the degree of interest shown.

… Northern NSW native forests are to be fed into European furnaces as fuel to make electricity.

Here is the 10 minute Pre Film Preview – Gondwana Burning

It is password protected, the password is frontline.

David has asked our [CEC] attention and interest, he has provided the 9 minute Pre Film Preview and requested feedback regarding the degree of interest shown.

Reply below: …

Share

Everyday is World Environment Day. UN theme for this year is: ‘It’s Time for Nature.’

The UN has declared “It’s Time for Nature” as the theme for this year’s World Environment Day. To explain the theme the UN says, “The foods we eat, the air we breathe, the water we drink and the climate that makes our planet habitable all come from nature. Yet, these are exceptional times in which nature is sending us a message: To care for ourselves we must care for nature. It’s time to wake up. To take notice. To raise our voices. It’s time to build back better for People and Planet.”

World Environment Day 2020

.

Caldera Environment Centre

Share

DEAR EU PARLIAMENT, REGARDING FOREST BIOMASS

“… the renewable energy directive … amend the present directive … avoid expansive harm to the world’s forests and the acceleration of climate change.

“The flaw in the directive lies in provisions that would let countries, power plants and factories claim credit toward renewable energy targets for deliberately cutting down trees to burn them for energy.

“… cutting down trees for bioenergy releases carbon that would otherwise stay locked up in forests.

“… using wood deliberately harvested for burning will increase carbon in the atmosphere and increase warming for decades to centuries.

“Burning wood is inefficient and therefore emits far more carbon than burning fossil fuels for each kilowatt hour of electricity produced. read more

Share

Land-Clearing Must Stop

The North East Forest Alliance is calling for an immediate halt to land-clearing in the light of the Natural Resources Commission’s damning review showing that land-clearing has skyrocketed, the promised off-setting is not being implemented, Areas of Outstanding Biodiversity Value are not being protected, the regulatory map has not been released, and that land-clearing represents a biodiversity risk across north-east NSW.  
“This follows a damning report from the Auditor General last year finding the regulation of land-clearing was fraught with problems of weak processes, poor assessments, inadequate protection, limited monitoring and poor enforcement, NEFA spokesperson Dailan Pugh said.
“We are in a climate and extinction emergency, clearing more vegetation and releasing its carbon into the atmosphere is pouring more fuel onto the fire, it has to stop.
“Last year over half of north-east NSW’s remnant native vegetation was burnt with the likely death of over 350 million native mammals, birds, lizards and frogs, including thousands of Koalas.
“Many species of plants and animals have had their populations decimated and are teetering on the brink of extinction, it is outrageous that the NSW Government is now allowing land-clearing and logging to push many populations over the brink.
“The Natural Resources Commission’s belatedly released July 2019 report on land-clearing  gives another damning assessment of NSW’s land-clearing free-for-all, it is no wonder the Government suppressed it for so long.
“The NRC reveals that from June 2018 until May 2019, 45,553 hectares was approved to be cleared under the Government’s new Land Management (Native Vegetation) Code, excluding “invasive native species”.
“This was a massive increase from the average of 2,700 hectares per year between 2006/07 and 2016/17.
“Though the NRC are scathing in their assessment that the Government is only setting aside in protected areas a fraction of the area approved to be cleared, when the Government promised they would protect 2-4 times more than was cleared.
“On the north coast the NRC reveal only one fifth the area of the land cleared is being set aside, and this drops down to less than a tenth on the New England Tablelands.
“As the NRC point out, in the second reading speech to Parliament for the Biodiversity Conservation Act 2016, the then Minister for Primary Industries Niall Blair stated that ‘for each hectare cleared under the framework, it is estimated that between two and four hectares will be set aside and managed in perpetuity’ in order to conserve biodiversity values.
“The difference is even starker if the clearing of ‘invasive native species’ is accounted for as the Auditor General’s report last year identified that over 140,000 ha was also cleared under this dubious category.
“Because of the abject failure of the Government to live up to their promise to parliament, the NRC found there was a high biodiversity risk with nine of the eleven regions exceeding their biodiversity trigger thresholds.
“Land-clearing must stop, at least until there is a full assessment of the impacts of the bushfires on our imperilled wildlife, and the Environment Minister has fulfilled his responsibility to identify Areas of Outstanding Biodiversity Value, such as core Koala habitat, for protection.
“Land-clearing increases regional temperatures, reduces rainfalls and releases large quantities of carbon into the atmosphere, we cannot afford for it to continue, let alone escalate. We need to be planting more trees to take up carbon, not bulldozing them.” Mr. Pugh said. read more

Share